What Happens When Two Doctors Disagree About Your Work Restrictions?

A common problem injured workers face is when two doctors offer conflicting opinions about whether they can return to work. For example:

An orthopedic specialist says you should stay off work for a month, but on the same day, the company doctor clears you to return.

So which opinion should you follow?

Start by Talking to Both Doctors

It’s possible the doctors aren’t aware of each other’s recommendations or don’t have the full picture. Make sure:

• Both doctors understand your job duties
• Both doctors know about the other’s opinion

Miscommunication can often be resolved by making sure everyone is on the same page.

Whose Opinion Matters More?

In most cases, especially with serious injuries like back trauma, the opinion of a treating orthopedic specialist will carry more weight than that of a general company physician. The Iowa Workers’ Compensation Commissioner often gives more credibility to specialists with focused expertise.

What If the Disagreement Continues?

If the dispute isn’t resolved after clarification:

• Notify the work comp insurance company immediately
• Document your symptoms and limitations
• Consider speaking with a qualified work comp attorney

Sometimes company doctors are pressured to return employees to work too soon. In these cases, your health and legal rights may be best protected by relying on the specialist’s opinion.

Don’t risk worsening your injury.

If you're facing conflicting medical advice after a work injury, we can help you understand your options and advocate for your health. Contact Lawyer Lawyer Dutton Drake & Conklin LLP of Urbandale, IA today for a free consultation.